Dealer Diagnostic
Your Website Is Still the Biggest Lever

Zach Billings

November 19, 2026
November 19, 2026
Dealer Diagnostic (Episode 6) The Website Is Still The Biggest Lever

 

In this seventh installment of Dealer Diagnostic, we sit down with Zach Billings, Wikimotive’s Co-Founder and CEO, to discuss why your dealership’s website is still your biggest lever for turning marketing traffic into leads. Zach explains how to simplify calls to action, evaluate the mobile shopping experience, and determine whether a conversion problem starts with the traffic you’re attracting or what happens once shoppers arrive. Read the full transcript below or watch the conversation.

[Embed Episode 7 video here]

Why is your website still your most important marketing asset in the AI era?

The website is the most important asset a dealership has because, ultimately, it’s the thing that all of your marketing traffic lands on, and it has the responsibility for converting it into opportunity.

So your website is a blank slate when you first get it. Yes, it has some tools built onto it, and it has a couple of Why Buy’s that you might have handed the website provider, but like a house, you have to make it your own. And it’s nobody’s job to do that for you. You don’t have a vendor right now who knows exactly what it is that you want to see on your website, exactly what your priorities are, or what you’re willing to do in pursuit of more conversion rate optimization.

So not only can they not read your mind, but for most vendors, optimizing your website literally isn’t part of their job, even if you assume it would be. It’s not your SEO vendor’s job. It’s not your SEM vendor’s job. Hopefully, you have trusted partners who can help you make these decisions. But at the end of the day, it is your responsibility to go through your website and make sure that it works well and that it is streamlined to the vision and the functionality that you want for your consumers. And that makes it both the most important asset, in that it lands all of the traffic and converts it, and also the most challenging to curate into what you want it to be.

Dealer Takeaway: Assign someone at the dealership to own the website experience. Agree on what shoppers should be able to do, then clarify which partner can help with each improvement.

How do site structure, inventory merchandising, and content shape search performance?

The role of the website in modern search performance is less about the technical components that everyone assumes they should be focusing on and more about the consumer experience.

The ease of navigation, the ease of decision-making when it comes to fewer calls to action, better images of your cars, clearer pricing, more transparent pricing—the behavior that comes from that clarity and that ease of use is far more impactful to your search visibility than the technical components everybody wastes their time on.

Dealer Takeaway: Start on a common landing page and try to find a vehicle, confirm its price, and take the next step. Fix missing photos, unclear pricing, or confusing navigation wherever they slow you down.

Which mistakes with calls to action cost dealerships the most leads?

By far, the biggest mistake I see on dealership websites regarding conversion is having too many ways to convert. It’s too many CTAs. More is not better. This is a “less is more” situation.

You want to have just a few clear calls to action, and no two markets or brands are exactly the same when it comes to which ones perform best. A question I get from dealers a lot is, “Hey, you consult with so many dealers. You must know exactly which buttons work best.” And the answer is, I have a lot of direction that I can give you. I can tell you, “Hey, you’re a Honda dealer, and I know what’s worked for other Honda dealers, but in your market, with your demographics, it may be a bit different.”

So the next stage there is, after you reduce, you also test. And conveniently, Google Analytics gives us all the data we need for this. We can see how many people click on each of the CTAs and which marketing channels they come from. And that is all the clue you need to figure out which verbiage worked best and which one was best aligned with consumers’ desires. Was it payment? Was it just, you know, “Secure My Price”? Was it trade value?

And then what you can do is tweak the verbiage one month at a time, one button at a time, and measure whether your conversion rate went up or down. It’s a very easy thing to measure, and it can help you make tactical decisions after you’ve reduced the number of buttons so you can get the right verbiage in place.

Dealer Takeaway: Remove redundant buttons, then test the wording of one remaining button at a time. Track clicks and completed inquiries separately so you can tell whether more shoppers actually followed through.

How much does the mobile shopping experience affect dealership results?

Everybody knows that the mobile experience on your website has a huge impact on results. Everyone knows that more than 50% of consumers come from mobile. Everyone knows that Google is prioritizing the mobile experience over the desktop experience. It’s common knowledge.

Yet we all look at our websites on desktop and make our decisions based on the desktop experience. Why? Right? At the end of the day, you’re trying to take all of this info on your desktop and compress it down into this tiny screen.

You have to do a lot more scrolling, and it changes the way that you interact with that information. When you’re going to evaluate your website to decide if it’s any good, do it on mobile. And here’s a pro tip. Right-click on desktop, hit “Inspect,” change the device, and you can see on your desktop what it looks like on mobile so you don’t have to do it all on your phone.

Dealer Takeaway: Use a phone to find a vehicle, check its price, and submit a test inquiry. Pay attention to how much scrolling it takes and whether the next step is easy to see and tap.

How does limited competition among OEM-approved website providers affect dealers?

Dealerships experience so many limitations because of OEM requirements on website platforms, but the limitation isn’t the requirements themselves.

The limitation that’s coming from this ecosystem is the lack of competition.

Website providers are a broken economic system.

When we have competition and a free market—I’m getting into, you know, capitalism theory now—but when we have open competition and a free market, we get improvement, not to mention competitive pricing. And what we have right now is OEM requirements that create this locked and even playing field where there are only small differentiators between platforms, and there’s only a certain number of entrants that are allowed to come into the space.

When a newcomer with a better mousetrap, right, comes into the market in automotive, they can’t just break into the OEM space, and therefore they don’t impact the innovation, or lack thereof, of the incumbents. So what we have is a space that is fundamentally broken by a lack of incentive for the website vendors to do better and to price more aggressively, and it’s hurting all dealers universally.

Dealer Takeaway: When your provider says a change isn’t possible, ask whether the limitation comes from an OEM requirement or the platform itself. Ask what alternatives are available before deciding how to proceed.

When traffic isn’t converting, how can dealers tell where the problem starts?

If traffic isn’t converting at the rate you expect, the first thing you should do is look at the channels you’re measuring.

One of the most common mistakes I see among dealers who talk to me about traffic and marketing is that they assume volume should be measured in absolute terms, and that’s not an accurate way to look at it. The easiest example is that social traffic is usually very high in the funnel, and you should expect a low conversion rate. Organic traffic is, on average, much lower in the funnel, and you should expect a high conversion rate, unless, of course, it’s blog traffic, in which case that might throw a wrench in the works.

So you have to look at each channel independently. You have to decide what you’re measuring and what the normal benchmark is for that channel. Don’t look at your website as a whole, because it depends on what you’re spending on each channel.

The other side of that is, once you’ve broken it down to just, let’s say, social or just organic or just paid, and you’re benchmarking against some industry standard or your 20 group, for instance, and you’re seeing that you’re lagging, now the place to look is your calls to action. Look at the data behind those calls to action, see which ones are being used, and start to test changes to the wording.

Dealer Takeaway: Break out conversion rates by channel and account for where visitors land. If a source is underperforming against a comparable baseline, inspect its landing pages and calls to action before changing the budget.

If you could invest in one website improvement this year, where would you start?

Pay yourself for a day off.

Mess with your website. Figure out what isn’t working. There are multiple things.

Do it on desktop. Do it on mobile. Then also give some instructions to your brother-in-law, your mom, your son—a bunch of people who are not directly in the business—and have them do the same.

Put the information that you get together. Go to your trusted vendors other than your website vendor first and ask for their input on what you found. Then go to your website vendor and ask for changes.

Dealer Takeaway: Block out time for a hands-on website review. Give people outside the dealership specific tasks on desktop and mobile, document where they get stuck, and bring a prioritized list of fixes to your website provider.

Author